A sweet, spiced chicken stew that has a delicious barbecue-y-ness to it

Unfortunately named but delicious ancient Roman dessert made with cheese, honey, and bay leaves

Delicious roasted pork with a peppery and sweet stuffing that has an odd chewy texture

Ancient Roman version of mushy peas, this dish is very Roman in that it is a strange combination of flavors, including savory garum and sweet honey

Boiled cured pork fat that is quite salty and tastes kind of like bacon with a hint of dill

A simple vinegar drink that was the Gatorade of ancient Rome

Roasted heart stuffed with bacon and leeks and basted with honey

A simple, refreshing cocktail that was part of an English sailor’s daily ration in the Caribbean

An essential part of a soldier’s or sailor’s diet: overly dry, bland bread that would last forever

Very different from modern store-bought eggnog! It’s sweet, creamy (but not thick), foamy, and very boozy. Really, really good

Not your mother’s gingerbread (but maybe your great²⁶-grandmother’s). Candy-like confection with a lot of ginger flavor and an unfortunate gritty texture, but is still really nice

Proto fried cheesecake bites dipped in honey. Easy, delicious, and they’d be great as a holiday appetizer

Very rich, very raisiny boiled Christmas pudding with a healthy dose of brandy

Non-custard pumpkin pie made from pumpkin slices, apple, dried fruit, and herbs. So, so good and one of the most popular Tasting History recipes

Real Elizabethan buttered beer that’s a cross between beer and a light spiced custard, or like beery eggnog? It’s delicious